| Pilot Vic | 70 | A H | Sholazar Basin | 1 | |
| Pilot Wizzlecrank | 15 | A H | | | |
| Pilot Xiggs Fuselighter | 45 | A H | | | |
| Pimgib | 39 | A H | Dire Maul | 1 | |
| Pin | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pincer X2 Crewmember | 80 | A H | | 10 | |
| Pincer X2 Crewmember | 81 | A H | | | |
| Pincer X2 Crewmember | 81 | A H | | | |
| Pincer X2 Crewmember | 80 - 81 | A H | | | |
| Ping Marlfur | 86 | A H | Valley of the Four Winds | 1 | |
| Ping Marlfur | 90 | A H | | | |
| Pink Peony | 90 | A H | | 1 | |
| Pio | 85 | A H | The Jade Forest | 1 | |
| Pipthwack | 72 | A H | Grizzly Hills | 1 | |
| Pirate Bodyguard | 90 | A H | | | |
| Pirate Party Crasher | 3 - 4 | A H | Kezan | 43 | |
| Pirate Party Crasher | 4 - 5 | A H | Kezan | 12 | |
| Pissed Vendor | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pissed not a Vendor | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pit Announcer | 65 | A H | Old Hillsbrad Foothills | 1 | |
| Pit Boss Buxdoggle | 90 | A H | | | |
| Pit Spectator | 68 - 69 | A H | Old Hillsbrad Foothills | 7 | |
| Pit-Fighting Spectator | 73 - 74 | A H | Grizzly Hills | 14 | |
| Piter Verance | 41 | A H | Dustwallow Marsh | 1 | |
| Pithwick | 30 | A H | Ironforge | 1 | |
| Pixel | 34 | A H | Ashenvale | 1 | |
| Piznik | 20 | A H | | | |
| Pizznukle | 33 | A H | | | |
| Plaguebringer Tillinghast | 71 | A H | Howling Fjord | 1 | |
| Plagued Dragonflayer Handler | 69 - 70 | A H | Howling Fjord | 8 | |
| Plagued Dragonflayer Rune-Caster | 69 | A H | Howling Fjord | 3 | |
| Plagued Dragonflayer Tribesman | 70 | A H | Howling Fjord | 28 | |
| Plagued Magnataur | 70 - 71 | A H | Borean Tundra | 16 | |
| Plagued Snobold | 1 | A H | | | |
| Plaguemaw the Rotting | 45 | A H | Razorfen Downs | 1 | |
| Plaguewood Reanimator | 44 - 45 | A H | Eastern Plaguelands | 38 | |
| Plate Armor Vendor | 70 | A H | | | |
| Plate Armor Vendor | 1 | A H | | | |
| Plate Armor Vendor | 90 | A H | | | |
| Plate Glyph Vendor | 70 | A H | | | |
| Plate Glyph Vendor | 1 | A H | | | |
| Player Clone | 1 | A H | | | |
| Player Clone | 1 | A H | | | |
| Player Clone (TEMP) | 90 | A H | | | |
| Player Clone (TEMP) | 90 | A H | | | |
| Player Clone (TEMP) | 90 | A H | | | |
| Player Doppleganger | 35 | A H | Southern Barrens | 1 | |
| Player Mirror Image | 47 | A H | | | |
| Player Stunt Double | 1 | A H | | | |
| Player Stunt Double [INTERNAL ONLY] | 85 | A H | | | |