| Pygmy (Warrior) | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 84 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Ambusher | 85 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Brute | 85 | A H | Lost City of the Tol'vir | 4 | |
| Pygmy Cockatrice | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Cockatrice | 1 | A H | Darkmoon Island | 9 | |
| Pygmy Direhorn | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Firebreather | 85 | A H | Lost City of the Tol'vir | 3 | |
| Pygmy Oaf | 83 | A H | Uldum | 14 | |
| Pygmy Scout | 85 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Scout | 83 | A H | Uldum | 15 | |
| Pygmy Surf Crawler | 2 - 3 | A H | Durotar | 95 | |
| Pygmy Thief | 83 | A H | Uldum | 16 | |
| Pygmy Tide Crawler | 9 - 10 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Venom Web Spider | 18 - 19 | A H | | | |
| Pygmy Witchdoctor | 6 | A H | The Lost Isles | 2 | |
| Pygmy Witchdoctor | 1 | A H | The Lost Isles | 1 | |
| Pyke Meadbeard | 90 | A H | Valley of the Four Winds | 1 | |
| Pyrachnis | 85 | A H | | | |
| Pyramid Watcher | 85 | A H | Uldum | 2 | |
| Pyrecraw | 85 | A H | Blackwing Descent | 1 | |
| Pyrelord | 85 | A H | Molten Front | 1 | |
| Pyrelord | 85 | A H | Molten Front | 1 | |
| Pyreshell Scuttler | 81 | A H | | 45 | |
| Pyrestar Demolisher | 90 | A H | Isle of Thunder | 1 | |
| Pyrewood Armorer | 14 - 15 | A H | | | |
| Pyrewood Elder | 14 - 15 | A H | | | |
| Pyrewood Leatherworker | 14 - 15 | A H | | | |
| Pyrewood Sentry | 14 - 15 | A H | | | |
| Pyrewood Tailor | 14 - 15 | A H | | | |
| Pyrewood Torch Target 001 | 18 | A H | Silverpine Forest | 1 | |
| Pyrewood Torch Target 002 | 18 | A H | Silverpine Forest | 1 | |
| Pyrewood Torch Target 003 | 18 | A H | Silverpine Forest | 1 | |
| Pyrewood Watcher | 13 - 14 | A H | | | |
| Pyrite Rockling | 1 | A H | | | |
| Pyrite Rockling | 81 | A H | Deepholm | 12 | |
| Pyrite Safety Container | 80 | A H | | | |
| Pyrite Stonetender | 83 | A H | Deepholm | 1 | |
| Pyrium Lodestone | 83 | A H | Deepholm | 1 | |
| Pyroguard Emberseer | 59 | A H | Blackrock Spire | 1 | |