| Captain Idrilae | 70 | A H | | | |
| Captain Ironhill | 32 | A H | | | |
| Captain Ironhill's Ghost | 32 | A H | Hillsbrad Foothills | 1 | |
| Captain Irontree | 83 | A H | Mount Hyjal | 1 | |
| Captain Irontree | 85 | A H | Molten Front | 2 | |
| Captain Iskandar | 74 | A H | Dragonblight | 1 | |
| Captain Jake | 1 | A H | | | |
| Captain Jake Sones | 90 | A H | Tol Barad Peninsula | 1 | |
| Captain Jekyll | 35 | A H | Hillsbrad Foothills | 1 | |
| Captain John Brookman | 80 | A H | | 1 | |
| Captain Joseph Holley | 80 | A H | Icecrown | 1 | |
| Captain Julian McWeaksauce | 1 | A H | | | |
| Captain Keelhaul | 35 | A H | | 1 | |
| Captain Kelisendra | 11 | A H | Eversong Woods | 1 | |
| Captain Kendall | 80 | A H | Icecrown | 1 | |
| Captain Kerwin | 90 | A H | Stormwind City | 2 | |
| Captain Keyton | 22 | A H | Hillsbrad Foothills | 1 | |
| Captain Korfang | 1 | A H | | | |
| Captain Korthok | 90 | A H | Dustwallow Marsh | 1 | |
| Captain Krazz | 85 | A H | | 1 | |
| Captain Krazz | 85 | A H | Azshara | 1 | |
| Captain Krazz | 85 | A H | Twilight Highlands | 1 | |
| Captain Krick Wrenchnozzle | 40 | A H | | 1 | |
| Captain Kroghan | 65 - 66 | A H | Nagrand | 1 | |
| Captain Kromcrush | 47 | A H | Dire Maul | 1 | |
| Captain Kronkh | 84 | A H | Uldum | 1 | |
| Captain Krosh | 63 | A H | Zangarmarsh | 1 | |
| Captain Lancy Revshon | 60 | A H | Stormwind City | 1 | |
| Captain Maloy | 90 | A H | | | |
| Captain Margun | 84 | A H | Uldum | 1 | |
| Captain Matok | 85 | A H | The Jade Forest | 1 | |
| Captain McFerris | 82 | A H | | 1 | |
| Captain Melrache | 12 | A H | Tirisfal Glades | 1 | |
| Captain Metlek | 56 | A H | Blasted Lands | 1 | |
| Captain Morris | 7 | A H | Gilneas | 1 | |
| Captain Mousson | 90 | A H | Dustwallow Marsh | 1 | |
| Captain Mulkey | 90 | A H | Krasarang Wilds | 1 | |
| Captain Nials | 41 | A H | Arathi Highlands | 1 | |
| Captain Noteo | 60 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Dell | 1 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 70 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 65 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 65 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 65 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 65 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 65 | A H | | | |
| Captain O'Neal | 65 | A H | | | |
| Captain Obvious | 1 | A H | | | |
| Captain Olster | 69 | A H | Howling Fjord | 1 | |
| Captain Ook | 90 | A H | Unga Ingoo | 1 | |