| Pew | Chair | 1 | |
| Pheromone Mine | Goober | 4 | |
| Pickled Eagle Egg | Container | 10 | |
| Pickled Herring | Generic | 1 | |
| Pickled Sludge | Spell Focus | 2 | |
| Pierce's Pistols | Generic | 1 | |
| Pierce's Pistols | Generic | 1 | |
| Pig and Whistle Tavern | Generic | 1 | |
| Pile of Ash | Spell Focus | 1 | |
| Pile of Bones | Container | 1 | |
| Pile of Bones | Container | 7 | |
| Pile of Burning Books | Generic | 1 | |
| Pile of Candy | Generic | 10 | |
| Pile of Crusader Skulls | Spell Focus | 1 | |
| Pile of Explosives | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Pile of Leaves | Container | 27 | |
| Pile of Leaves | Container | 13 | |
| Pile of Scraps | Container | 1 | |
| Pile of Scraps | Container | 1 | |
| Pile of Skulls | Container | 1 | |
| Pilfered Cannonballs | Container | 17 | |
| Pilfered Pumpkin | Container | 6 | |
| Pilfered Pumpkin | Container | 3 | |
| Pilfered Pumpkin | Container | 11 | |
| Pilfered Pumpkin | Container | 8 | |
| Pilfered Supplies | Container | 10 | |
| Pilfered Supplies | Container | 14 | |
| Pilgrim's Bounty Cooking Fire | Spell Focus | 7 | |
| Pillaclencher's Ornate Pillow | Container | 1 | |
| Pillaged Loot Sack | Container | 11 | |
| Pillar of Amethyst | Container | 1 | |
| Pillar of Diamond | Container | 1 | |
| Pillar of Opal | Container | 1 | |
| Pillow | Generic | 6 | |
| Pillow | Generic | 7 | |
| Pillow | Generic | 11 | |
| Pinup Calendar | Generic | 1 | |
| Pirate Accuracy Increasing Fire | Goober | 53 | |
| Pirate Booty | Container | 8 | |
| Pirate Booty | Container | 9 | |
| Pirate Booty | Container | 4 | |
| Pirate Booty | Container | 10 | |
| Pirate Day Music Doodad | Generic | 1 | |
| Pirate Hat | Goober | 2 | |
| Pirate Ship | Destructible Building | 1 | |
| Pirate Ship | Destructible Building | 1 | |
| Pirate Ship | Destructible Building | 1 | |
| Pirate Ship | Destructible Building | 1 | |
| Pirate Ship | Destructible Building | 1 | |
| Pirate Ship | Destructible Building | 1 | |