| Primordius Room Grate | Door | 1 | |
| Primordius Room Grate | Door | 1 | |
| Primordius Room Grate | Door | 1 | |
| Primordius Room Grate | Door | 1 | |
| Primordius Room Grate | Door | 1 | |
| Prince's Chest Aura | Generic | 1 | |
| Princess Stillpine's Cage | Door | 1 | |
| Prismatic Mojo | Container | 6 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Cell Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Door | Door | 1 | |
| Prison Portcullis | Door | 2 | |
| Prison Seal | Door | 1 | |
| Pristine Crane Egg | Container | 8 | |
| Pristine Owl Feather | Container | 8 | |
| Private Library Door | Door | 1 | |
| Professor Paleo's Bones 1 | Generic | 1 | |
| Professor Paleo's Bones 2 | Generic | 1 | |
| Professor Paleo's Shovel | Generic | 1 | |
| Projection of the Arcanomicon | Generic | 1 | |
| Prospector Khrona's Notes | Container | 1 | |
| Prospector Soren's Maps | Container | 1 | |
| Protected Unga Keg | Goober | 1 | |
| Protectorate Tracer | Generic | 3 | |
| Protodrake Egg | Generic | 8 | |
| Proton Accelerator Controller | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Proton Accelerator Controller | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Proton Accelerator Controller | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Proton Accelerator Controller | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Prototype Console | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Prototype Reaper Instruction Manual | Text | 1 | |
| Proving Grounds Barricade | Door | 8 | |
| Pteradon Skeleton | Text | 1 | |
| Pteradon Skeleton | Text | 1 | |
| Pterrordax Observation Lever | Spell Caster | 1 | |
| Puesto de vigilancia de Costsur | Spell Focus | 1 | |
| Puesto de vigilancia de Pico Nidal | Spell Focus | 1 | |
| Puesto de vigilancia de Theramore | Spell Focus | 1 | |
| Pulsing Crystal | Quest Giver | 1 | |
| Pulverized Gargoyle Teeth | Container | 11 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 139 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 25 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 1 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 1 | |