| Plaguelands | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaguewood Fire (Small) | Generic | 17 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plaque 01 | Generic | 1 | |
| Plate Armor & Shields | Generic | 1 | |
| Plate and Mail Protection | Generic | 1 | |
| Plate-n-Chain | Generic | 2 | |
| Platform | Generic | 5 | |
| Platform Control Panel | Generic | 1 | |
| Platter | Generic | 3 | |
| Poison | Generic | 1 | |
| Poison Vial | Generic | 1 | |
| Polyformic Acid Potion Highlight | Generic | 1 | |
| Pony Rides! | Generic | 1 | |
| Pool Statue | Generic | 1 | |
| Portable Oil Collector | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal Hub | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal Hub | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal Hub | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal Hub | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal from Shattrath City | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal to Dalaran | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal to Inner Maraudon | Generic | 1 | |
| Portal to Moonglade | Generic | 2 | |
| Portal to Stormwind | Generic | 1 | |
| Post | Generic | 2 | |
| Poster Knife | Generic | 16 | |
| Potts' Plates | Generic | 1 | |
| Power Coil | Generic | 2 | |
| Power Core Fragment | Generic | 7 | |
| Pre Moonwell | Generic | 1 | |
| Present BIG | Generic | 8 | |
| Present BIG | Generic | 8 | |
| Priest | Generic | 1 | |
| Priest Challenge Set Armor | Generic | 1 | |
| Prince's Chest Aura | Generic | 1 | |
| Professor Paleo's Bones 1 | Generic | 1 | |
| Professor Paleo's Bones 2 | Generic | 1 | |
| Professor Paleo's Shovel | Generic | 1 | |
| Projection of the Arcanomicon | Generic | 1 | |
| Protectorate Tracer | Generic | 3 | |
| Protodrake Egg | Generic | 8 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 139 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 25 | |
| Pumpkin | Generic | 1 | |